Showing posts with label housing crisis. Show all posts
Showing posts with label housing crisis. Show all posts

Monday, November 7, 2011

Do As I Say, Not As I Do - The Dichotomy Between Washington And The Rest Of The Country

One of the strengths of the United States had always been the diffusion of power throughout the population. "One person, one vote" was a great way to make sure that power, wealth, and freedom was dispersed to everyone, not concentrated in the hands of just a small group of people. Throughout history, concentration of power, whether it was in the French monarchy, the Soviet Politburo, or vicious dictators, was a surefire way to restrict freedom and the richness of life for the masses.

I say that this "was" one of the strengths of America since if you are observing what is going on in this country recently, our votes are becoming more and more less important while the power and freedom in this country is becoming more and more concentrated in Washington, the home of our Federal political class. Consider:

1) In Washington, according to a Bloomberg report that was summarized  in the November 4, 2011 issue of The Week magazine, Washington D.C. is now the wealthiest metro area in the country, with the typical D.C. household having an average income of $84,523.

In the rest of the country, as reported in that same issue of  The Week by the Washington Post, half of all U.S. workers earned less than $26,364 in 2010, which was the lowest median wage level since 1999. A household, in the rest of the country, with two average earners would earn only about $52,000 a year, roughly 40% less than a household in the Washington area.

CSM Monitor recently reported that that country's standard of living "has fallen longer and more steeply over the past three years" than at any time since the government started tracking the statistic over fifty years ago. I am assuming this trend is not happening in the Washington D.C. area.

2) In Washington, according to CBS News, as reported in the November 11, 2011 issue of The Week magazine, members of the House of Representatives earn over $170,000 a year, more than three times the average household income of the typical American household. However, those Congress people will be in Congressional session only 109 workdays in 2012 while in recess for 151 weekdays, primarily to be able to focus more on their re-election than the business of the country. In January, August, and October of 2012, they are scheduled to work six days, three days, and five days, respectively.

In the rest of the country, 14 million Americans do not have a job, millions more are underemployed, and millions are working two or more jobs in order to make ends meet. The vast majority of Americans are working well over 109 workdays a year for far less than $170,000.

3) According to a June 2, 2011 issue of the Wall Street Journal, the Washington D.C. area is the only metro area in the country where housing prices increased on a year over year basis, according to the S&P/Case Shiller home price index. This was caused by a number of factors including stable employment, fewer foreclosures, and a steady stream of house hunters.  According to the Journal's report, other surveys indicate sales in the D.C. area are approaching boom-time levels.

In the rest of the country, housing prices continued to decline in most metro areas, foreclosures are clogging the housing market in the rest of the country, with no relief in sight, and the housing market in most U.S. metro areas is no where close to "boom times."

4) In Washington, over 50% of the members of Congress are in the top 1% of income earners in the country, according to an analysis in the November 4, 2011 issue of The Week magazine.

In the rest of the country, 1% of the population is in the top 1% of the income earners in the country.

5) In Washington, it apparently does not matter whether or not you do your job, you get to keep your job regardless. The prime example of this phenomenon comes from a recent article in Politco that was summarized  in the November 11, 2011 issue of The Week magazine. This article reported that although the Dodd-Frank financial reform bill was signed into law 15 months ago, the government agencies responsible for writing the required regulations of the law have missed more than 75% of the law's implementation deadlines.

In the rest of the country, if a typical worker missed over 75% of their deadlines, they would quickly be replaced by someone from the millions and millions of other Americans who are in need of a full time job.

6) According to a July 21, 2011 article in the National Journal, the lobbying business in Washington continues to thrive. Lobbyists continue to help their corporate and union clients to influence the government regulations needed as a result of Obama Care, Dodd-Frank, and other legislation and find ways around the tightening of earmarks to keep special interest money flowing. 

In the rest of the country, every American has only one vote to oppose the billions and billions of lobbyist dollars currently flowing into Washington to influence special interests.

7) In Washington, the political class enjoys inexpensive, high quality health care, receives automatic annual pay raises regardless of how poorly they perform their jobs, and enjoys very lucrative traditional pensions.

In the rest of the country, tens of millions of Americans are about to be lose their current health insurance coverage and be forced into government run health insurance exchanges because of how poorly Obama Care was written, most Americans are happy to just have a job, never mind getting a raise, and very few working people outside of Washington are now able to get a traditional pension.

You get the idea. As power gets more and more concentrated, power gets more and more easily to corrupt. As freedom and liberty get more and more concentrated, freedom and liberty get easier to restrict. We are quickly devolving into the French monarchy or the Soviet Politburo (made that much more ominous by Obama's word choice of "czars" for the shadow government he has established in the White House).

None of these developments bode well for liberty. To combat this creeping political class domination, several steps from "Love My Country, Loathe My Government" need to be taken quickly to save our democracy:
  • Step 39 - this step would impose term limits on all Federal politicians so that they would be "one and done," serving one term in office and then retiring from national politics. Today's politicians are more concerned about staying in office then fixing what is wrong with the country. Restricting them to one term would put a sense of urgency and focus back into their work habits.
  • Step 37 - this step would move the performance appraisal function into the hands of Americans citizens, they would determine if and how much of a pay raise politicians would receive each year. No more automatic pay raises for Washington.
  • Step 34 - this step would kick Congressional committee members off of their respective committees for bad or non-performance of their jobs on that committee. It is called accountability, no more free passes on bad performance.
  • Step 41 - would prevent any Congressional member or President from drawing a Federal paycheck if their net worth was over $3 million when they came into office. Given that 50% of Congress falls into the upper 1% of the nation's earners, this should not be a hardship for most members of the Federal political class. These people should be in Washington to serve the nation and not to serve their personal wealth needs.
  • Step 42 - this step establishes financial benchmarks that would cut off Secret Service coverage and other government expense coverage after a President leaves office if that President was wealthy enough to afford his or her own protection. Again, serving the country in political office should be a service calling, not an opened ended bank account for multi-millionaires.
  • Step 9 - this step would terminate the tradition government pension benefit for all Federal workers hired in the future and would terminate the traditional pension benefit for all current and past members of Congress immediately. This would force the current and past set of politicians to survive their retirement on Social Security, 401k-like plans, and their personal savings, just like the rest of most of America.
  • Step 6 - this step would allow only individual Americans to contribute to election campaigns, hopefully removing much of the oversized corporate, union, PAC, lobbyists, and other special interest money flowing into Washington, money that dilutes the cherished "one person, one vote" principle.
The ultimate first step would be to defeat and remove all incumbents from office next November. We have to find a way to eliminate the dichotomy of haves vs. have nots in this country, i.e., a dichotomy of the out-of-touch political class vs. the rest of America. Failure to do so will result in the further development of an elitist, pompous political class who enrich themselves while never solving the problems facing the nation.





Our book, "Love My Country, Loathe My Government - Fifty First Steps To Restoring Our Freedom And Destroying The American Political Class" is now available, at http://www.loathemygovernment.com .It is also available online at Amazon and Barnes and Noble. Please pass our message of freedom onward. Let your friends and family know about our websites and blogs, ask your library to carry the book, and respect freedom for both yourselves and others everyday.


Please visit the following sites for freedom:




http://www.loathemygovernment.com/
http://www.cato.org/
http://www.robertringer.com/
http://realpolichick.blogspot.com/
http://www.flipcongress2010.com/
http://www.reason.com/
http://www.repealamendment.com/

Monday, May 24, 2010

More Reasons To Expect The Financial Reform Legislation To Fail

A few days ago we went into detail about how the new financial markets reform legislation that the Senate recently passed (their version must now by merged with the House of Representatives version) is likely to be ineffective for the simple reason that it did nothing to reform or keep in check two of the biggest causes of the economic meltdown: irrational and risky behavior by Fannie Mae and Freddie Mac. We calculated that these two Federal agencies were costing the American taxpayer about $7 billion a month to keep them solvent and that the proposed legislation did not nothing to get them in line from a lending, accounting, and solvency perspective.

If Fannie and Freddie were not enough to doom the effectiveness of the reform legislation, consider an Associated Press (AP) article by Daniel Wagner that appeared on May 24, 2010, titled, "New Financial Rules Might Not Prevent Next Crisis." Mr. Wagner takes a detailed look at the many components that the proposed law covers and provides some in-depth analysis of why the bill may fail in each area:
  • Derivatives - many believe that these types of financial products not only helped to pump up the housing market but also magnified the chaos of the bursting housing bubble. Apparently, business lobbying groups got the new rules on visibility for derivative trading diluted so that only the big banks are affected. The old, dangerous ways of doing business for most companies will continue with no new visibility rules.
  • Weak banking oversight - prior to the crash, many government oversight organizations failed to foresee the coming financial meltdown and the risky behavior that was causing the crisis and allowed some industry companies to avoid oversight altogether. While this legislation supposedly tightens regulation oversight, there are two problems. Banking lobbyists got serious concessions and a diluting of oversight regulation and many government agencies involved in oversight also lobbied the government (figure that one out, government agencies lobbying government politicians) to protect their turf, resulting in virtually no changes to the government's regulatory hierarchy, a hierarchy that failed miserably in foreseeing the latest recession clouds and storm.
  • Too Big To Fail - according to Mr. Wagner, the bill does very little to prevent big banks from getting bigger, implying that taxpayers may still have to pay up for risky and ill timed behavior of the biggest banks in the future.
  • Consumer Protection - a lot of the foreclosure and housing problems were caused when consumers took on mortgages and financing plans that they were not qualified for. This part of the bill is supposed to oversee banking products and financing plans and ban those products and offers that are thought to be too risky. However, the oversight in this bill would only extend to lending organizations with over $10 billion in assets. Smaller banks and more importantly, nonbanks, would not be be covered. Since many of the bad mortgages in the past were written by smaller mortgage brokers who sold the mortgages immediately after closing, regardless of how poor a credit risk the deal was, a root cause of the housing collapse, shady mortgage dealers, will not be addressed by this bill.
  • Credit Rating Agencies - credit rating agencies such as Moody's and Standard and Poor's failed miserably to detect bad mortgage securities and wrongly gave many of them high credit worthiness ratings. Obviously, most of these high rated securities,s backed by poorly performing mortgages, were disasters so this part of the bill tries to end the practice of banks choosing the credit agencies that rate their investment offerings. An independent board would assign rating agencies. However, the banks still would have to pay the credit rating agencies that are chosen to rate their investments so the incentive to overrate is still present.

Many would say this is a nice try but that is about all it is, a nice try. Many of the problems have not been addressed or they have been addressed in a haphazard or diluted way. The further concern is the House and Senate bills still have to be merged, probably resulting in more compromises and a further weakening of the legislation's intentions. At some point you have to ask: when does so much dilution and compromising result in a toothless bill? The political class will no doubt congratulate itself when the final law is passed but banks will still be too big to fail, underhanded small mortgage brokers and smaller banks will still be pushing bad financing products (which eventually get dumped on the taxpayer via Fannie Mae and Freddie Mac), the regulation hierarchy that failed so miserably a few years ago will still be in place, unseen derivative trading may still stalk the underbelly of the economy, and rating agencies will still be rating, and being paid by banks, to rate a banks investment offerings with the incentive to give a higher rating, while somewhat muted, still present.

Why are we stuck with such ineffective legislation? Possibly two reasons. First, as we have mentioned many times, the political class as an entity is not very smart when it comes to solving large, complex problems. In fact, I cannot even remember the last time they solved a major problem or resolved a major issue. Second, they may not have had a chance in this area since, according to the article, the following organizations lined up for input to the writing of the bill: U.S. Chamber of Commerce, Business Roundtable, Independent Community Bankers, the American Bankers Association, Federal regulatory agencies such as the FDIC, Goldman Sachs and other large banks, the payday lending industry, and the National Automobile Dealers Association.

Mr. Wagner reports that the financial services industry has donated about $2.3 billion to political candidates for Federal public office in the past twenty years. It has also spent $3.8 billion in pure lobbying expense since 1998, more than any other sector. Thus, is it any wonder that possibly the political class is looking out for their own interests and the interests of their re-election funders than the American taxpayer?

This is just another example where Step 39, term limits, as outlined in "Love My Country, Loathe My Government" would be needed. Most people, especially politicians, cannot be expected to act rationally and in the best interests of average Americans and the country as a whole when the banking or other industry is throwing billions of dollars in campaign funding at them. The only real solution is to make sure that re-election is not an option. Then, and only then, can we begin to take money out of the equation and maybe put the country's welfare back into the equation. While we are at it, lets also impose Step 6 which only allow individual citizens to contribute to any campaign and thus, take corporate, union, and PAC money totally out of the election process.

In conclusion, please remember our advice from yesterday's post as this so-called reform legislation moves forward - focus on what the unintended consequences are of the final law, not the intended aims of the law. The intended goals are highly unlikely to be attained, based on the discussion above, while the unintended consequences of such a large piece of legislation could be extensive.


Our new book, "Love My Country, Loathe My Government - Fifty First Steps To Restoring Our Freedom And Destroying The American Political Class" is now available at www.loathemygovernment.com. It is also available online at Amazon and Barnes and Noble. Please pass our message of freedom onward. Let your friends and family know about our websites and blogs, ask your library to carry the book, and respect freedom for both yourselves and others everyday.

Thursday, March 4, 2010

If You Laid Every Economist End-To-End...

The title of this blog is the beginning of an old joke that goes: If you laid every economist in the world end-to-end they would still not reach a conclusion. This joke came to mind as I was reading an article in the March 1, 2010 issue of Fortune magazine. It was written by Geoff Colvin and was titled: "Alan Greenspan Fights Back." Mr. Colvin basically wrote up an interview he had with Mr. Greenspan, focusing a lot of the effort on the hard economic times that resulted when the housing bubble burst.

The article refers to work done by John Taylor of Stanford University, a current friend and former co-worker of Greenspan. Taylor's analysis and publications portray the Federal Reserve Board actions under Greenspan's leadership to be misguided and those action created the disastrous housing collapse. Without going into too much detail, Taylor says that the Fed broke from a decades long practice by deviating from a long term economic management formula that was named after Taylor in 1993. The formula's inputs are the inflation rate, the target inflation rate, economic growth, and the economy's production capacity. By deviating from this long established, and highly successful formula, Taylor believes that the Greenspan Fed actually created the real estate boom and bust. His models show that if the Fed had stayed the course and continued utilizing the Taylor formula, housing starts would have stayed at about the late 1990s level and thus, no boom and no bust.

Greenspan, of course, disputes Taylor's work and the negative impact that the Greenspan Fed had on the economic crisis. His view is that the world changed, starting in 2002, where actions taken by the Fed were overwhelmed by the quickly growing economies like China that produced more wealth and savings then ever before.. This wealth had to go somewhere and a lot of it landed in the global real estate market, raising prices and depressing the cost of capital which made money cheaper which raised housing prices, etc.

Taylor comes back and dismisses this point to which Greenspan counters Taylor's counter point. Rather than hash out the details any further, as a layman, I have my observations:
  • These are obviously two very smart people, that have dedicated their lives to understanding markets and economies and neither one of them saw this economic crisis ("This is a once-in-a-century event." - Greenspan quote) coming until it hit.
  • After the crisis hit and data was available for post mortem analysis, they cannot not come close to agreeing on what the underlying cause was even though they are looking at the exact same data.
  • Congress was no better. Congressman Barney Frank and Senator Chris Dodd, Democrats who chaired their respective Congressional committees regarding housing, never saw the crisis coming either until it hit them in the face.
  • If two of the smarter economists in the country cannot agree on the root cause of the economic collapse, what chance does Congress have of understanding the root cause and enacting legislation to prevent it in the future? Given the track record of the political class, I would bet that chance is extremely low. Most of them are not trained economists, they are lawyers, so good luck with any productive regarding economic policy coming from them.
Maybe it is time for all of us, but especially the politicians, to admit that we cannot control the world from Washington because the world has gotten just too complex. You cannot have 400-500 lawyers sitting around debating some of these major issues (economic reform, health care overhaul, etc.) that are maybe just to complex to define, understand, or control. If Taylor and Greenspan cannot agree on a root cause of the housing crisis after the fact, then Obama and the rest of the D.C. mob are not going to be any more coherent in their understanding.

Rather than try to control the world, maybe the political class should try to make sure that the basics are in place and let us, the citizens, make our own decisions as we see the world and how the world affects us personally. In order to get the foundation put in place, the government would have to do the following basic but highly important basics:
  • Get the national debt and deficit spending under control in order to insure all Americans are working with a fiscally sound currency.
  • Get the national debt under control and deficit spending under control so that Americans could keep more and more of their wealth and use that wealth as they see fit, not as the political class sees fit. In this complex world, each of us has differnet needs, risk tolerances, and capabilities, let us decide how to function in the world based on our own points of view. 400-500 lawyers have no chance of getting that right for 300 million Americans.
  • Re-instate the concept that this country allows you to be wildly successful and to wildly fail, the amount of wildness being up to the individual. If a company (e.g. Citi Bank, GM, etc.) or a government agency (e.g. Freddie Mac, Fannie Mae, etc.) fails miserably at what they do, there has to be repercussions and not salvation via taxpayer bailouts.

Fiscally sound currency, high retention of our wealth, and the knowledge that we can be as successful as we want individually, regardless of how complex the world is, would make for a better America for the ordinary person. As mentioned many times in "Love My Country, Loathe My Government," if we make the government significantly smaller and give them less to do, then maybe they can finally do some of the basic things right. Heavens knows that that is not the case today. If all of the polticians were laid end-to-end, they also would would not reach a conclusion but in the process they would waste a lot of money, divide the country, and bankrupt the currency. If Greenspan and Taylor cannot agree, the politicians will never agree, let us decide for ourselves.



Our new book, "Love My Country, Loathe My Government - Fifty First Steps To Restoring Our Freedom And Destroying The American Political Class" is now available at www.loathemygovernment.com. It is also available online at Amazon and Barnes and Noble.

Friday, January 15, 2010

High Taxes, Low Value - Part 3

I was going to move off of the High Taxes, Low Value theme but another prime example occurred to me this week. Recently, we have seen a lot of posturing by the political class and finger pointing about who caused the current housing, financial, and mortgage crises. The politicians are blaming the banking industry since they made obscene profits in the housing market. However, given that banks are private companies, in the business of making profits, shouldn't they be trying to do the exact thing that the politicians are blaming them for?

Given this profit motive, many would say the role of government is to make sure that the market functions fairly and openly. It is the government that should be protecting the citizenry and market from unscrupulous behavior and punish those that break the rules and laws. Consider for a moment, the following Federal government agencies that are involved in the banking and financial areas (and SHOULD have been on alert for trouble):
  1. Housing and Urban Development (HUD)
  2. Federal Housing Authority (FHA)
  3. Federal Housing Finance Agency (FHFA)
  4. Office Of Federal Housing Enterprise Oversight (OFHEO) - Recently melded into FHFA
  5. Federal Housing Finance Board (FHFB) - Recently melded into FHFA
  6. Government Sponsored Enterprise (GSE) - Recently melded into FHFA
  7. Fannie Mae
  8. Ginnie Mae
  9. Freddie Mac
  10. Federal Depository Insurance Corporation (FDIC)
  11. Treasury Department
  12. Federal Reserve Board
  13. House Of Representatives Financial Services Committee
  14. House Of Representatives Oversight and Government Reform Committee
  15. Senate Banking Committee
This list was derived after only a few minutes of searching on the Web to find Federal government organizations (I am sure there are others that I did not find) that SHOULD have been overseeing the housing, mortgage, and financial sectors of the market. This list does not include any House and Senate subcommittees that SHOULD have also been overseeing the housing, mortgage, and financial sectors of the market. This list does not include the many sub-agencies within the above Federal agencies that SHOULD have also been overseeing the housing, mortgage, and financial sectors of the market. This list does not include the hundreds of similar state government agencies that SHOULD have been overseeing the housing, mortgage, and financial sectors of the market.

Probably hundreds of government agencies, all staffed or run by the political class, involving thousands of employees and no one, anywhere foresaw the worst economic downturn since the Depression. No one saw the bogus mortgage applications being approved. No one saw the bad housing backed securities flooding the market. No one saw the dangerously high levels of housing inventory being created. No one saw (or decided not to act) on the blatant accounting abuses within Fannie Mae and Freddie Mac. No one saw the dangerous and risky assets on the books of many banks (failure of the Sarbanes-Oxley Act?).

Thus, despite paying incredibly high levels of taxes for protection, the government and political class provided absolutely no protection against the deep recession that will affect ordinary Americans for years. The question begs, why pay taxes at all for this lack of service? And to add insult to injury, after not doing their job in overseeing the activities in the banking, mortgage and financial areas, the political class turned around and gave billions and billions of taxpayer dollars to the very banks that were involved in the risky business that ruined their firm's financials. Those banks should have been allowed to die for their risky behavior and those bankers and such that were involved in those risky housing and mortgage ventures should have been out of a job.

The analogy I would use is like buying a new car that does not work. Not only do you not get your money back for the car, you are assessed an additional fee to pay the engineers and mechanics who built the car that did not work. The car is government regulation and protection and the additional fee is the bailout money given to banks. Makes no sense. And, even more insult to injury. Most of the bailed out banks have paid back their loans shortly after receiving them, indicating they were really not in danger of failing as the political class claimed they were.

Thus, another glaring example of high taxes for low value, or in this case, no value, given the deep impacts of the recession. This is a perfect application of Step 34 from "Love My Country, Loathe My Government" that would remove politicians from committee and subcommittee posts when those committees and subcommittees do not meet minimal performance standards. Given that no one on any committee or subcommittee saw the worst economic downturn coming until it hit them in the face, it would be a no brainer to remove all of them from their seats under Step 34.


Visit our website at www.loathemygovernment.com to order an autographed copy of the book, "Love My Country, Loathe My Government -Fifty First Steps To Restoring Our Freedom and Destroying The American Political Class" and to sign up for the cause. The book is also available online at Amazon and Barnes And Noble.