Showing posts with label panels. Show all posts
Showing posts with label panels. Show all posts

Sunday, April 4, 2010

I Told You So - The Only Viable Approach To Fix What Ails America

"Love My Country, Loathe My Government" contained five very important steps that are summarized here:
  • Step 23 - establish a panel of smart Americans from various disciplines, excluding politicians, that would do a comprehensive analysis of the current energy situation facing the country today, identifying and quantifying the root causes, leading to the development of several alternatives for alleviating that problem, alternatives that would be voted on by the American public and implemented by the political class.
  • Step 26 - establish a panel of smart Americans from various disciplines, excluding politicians, that would do a comprehensive analysis of the drug problem in the country today, identifying and quantifying the root causes, leading to the development of several alternatives for alleviating that problem, alternatives that would be voted on by the American public and implemented by the political class.
  • Step 27 - establish a panel of smart Americans from various disciplines, excluding politicians, that would do a comprehensive analysis of the failing public school problems facing the country today, identifying and quantifying the root causes, leading to the development of several alternatives for alleviating that problem, alternatives that would be voted on by the American public and implemented by the political class.
  • Step 28 - establish a panel of smart Americans from various disciplines, excluding politicians, that would do a comprehensive analysis of the rising health care cost problem facing the country, identifying and quantifying the root causes, leading to the development of several alternatives for alleviating that problem, alternatives that would be voted on by the American public and implemented by the political class.
  • Step 29 - establish a panel of smart Americans from various disciplines, excluding politicians, that would do a comprehensive analysis of the failed immigration policies facing the country, identifying and quantifying the root causes, leading to the development of several alternatives for alleviating that problem, alternatives that would be voted on by the American public and implemented by the political class.
The strategy leading to this approach is fourfold:
  1. None of these problems have been addressed by the ruling political class in America in at least the past forty years. Nixon declared war on drugs in the late 1960s and the drug problem has never been worse, especially when you consider the chaos below our southern border with Mexico. We lived through energy shortages with Carter in the 1970s and thirty five years later we still have no overarching and effective national energy strategy. During this time, we have allowed untold trillions of dollars to leave the country and build the prosperity of foreign countries. Although Reagan identified the core problems facing public education in the early 1980s, public education is still a failing proposition for many kids. There are at least ten million illegal immigrants in this country, not all of them just got here. Thus, we have had a failed or no immigration policy for quite some time. Bottom line, the current set of politicians have not solved anything over the decades.
  2. If you look back on our history as a nation, many of the large, positive changes were not implemented by politicians but by groups of dedicated, smart Americans, groups that knew how to analyze and solve problems based on their specialized education and background. Examples include the Manhattan Project that helped to end the second world war, the Apollo Moon Mission that allowed us to get to the moon first, the Grace Commission on Government Waste that at least temporarily slowed down wasteful government spending, the Social Security Commission that at least temporarily slowed down the approach of insolvency of the Social Security Administration, the Military Base Closing commission that allowed for wasteful or excess military bases to be shut down, and the 9-11 Commission that provided recommendations on how to improve the nation's security after the 9-11 attacks. In all cases, sitting politicians were removed from the vast majority of the decision process.
  3. As reported many times in this blog, the Federal wing of the political class does not know how to solve the big problems or does not want to solve the big problems, and thus, they work on such trivial legislation to regulate the sound volume of TV commercials, they work to eliminate the advertising of ED products on TV, they worry about how some people wear their pants too low, they spend time debating our college football should decide a national champion , and other non-important issues. This approach discussed above, using panels of smart Americans, is more proactive and puts the decision on what alternative to use in the hands of the people that need these problems solved, the voters.
  4. From a Constitutional perspective, although we would have Americans vote on what alternative plan they wanted for each crisis, Congress and the political class would probably have to be the final implementers of the plan, given the current structure of government we are working under.

Think about how much better life would be if just these five problems would be solved. Families would be comfortable knowing that their kids were getting a good education. Maybe crime would go down and we would be able to better treat fellow citizens with drug addiction problems. We would have a stable, efficient and low cost approach to health care costs and energy costs. We would have balanced the need for strong borders with a welcoming but selective immigration policy. Life would be pretty good. The best news is that the problems would have been addressed and solved, we would have done it ourselves, and would would not have to wait for the politicians to get around to it which is likely to never happen.

Getting back to the title of this post. "I Told You So...", a few recent publications indicate that maybe people are starting to see merit in this approach of using smart Americans, and not politicians, to solve our problems. In the April 5, 2010 edition of Business Week, writer Bob Nardelli suggested that an expert panel of smart Americans, in his case "business leaders who excel at making decisions that, despite budget constraints, drive growth and job creation", be created in order to alleviate the vexing question of lowering the unemployment rate. Despite spending untold hundreds of billions of dollars, the political class has been unable to reduce the unemployment rate. If you read the details of his suggestions and approach, it is very close to what was proposed in "Love My Country, Loathe My Government" in that his panel would question, analyze, quantify and then propose viable and cost efficient solutions. The White House and Congress would only be overseers and check points, not wasters of time, resources, and money.

David Brooks of the New York Times, recommended a similar approach in his April 4, 2010 column as it pertained to the skyrocketing deficits. He would put together a panel of handpicked Senators and Congressmen and women and stick them in a room for six months to come up with a comprehensive and effective deficit reduction program, using whatever resources they needed and whatever ideas looked good. This would remove the whole decision making process from the traditional way of doing business that we all know has resulted in no solutions. Although he would use politicians to sit on "the panel", his explanation in the article, which I will not go into today, on how to make the process has work as tremendous upside.

The status quo is no longer acceptable. The current approach to solving problems in DC is no longer acceptable, simply because it does not solve problems. Nardelli, Brooks, and "Love My Country, Loathe My Government" present a way to get things done now and not several decades later.


Our new book, "Love My Country, Loathe My Government - Fifty First Steps To Restoring Our Freedom And Destroying The American Political Class" is now available at www.loathemygovernment.com. It is also available online at Amazon and Barnes and Noble.

Saturday, February 20, 2010

Going Nuclear And Wasting More Taxpayer Money

Anyone who loves freedom and desires a much smaller, less intrusive and less expensive government, has not had a good year or so. The political class, under both Bush and Obama, have made a sham out of our economy and our free market system. Someone once said that: "Capitalism without the threat of bankruptcy and ruin is like Christianity without the threat of Hell." However, that is not what we have in America today. Tens of billions of taxpayer dollars were spent on the bailouts of Chrysler and GM even though it was the mismanagement of those companies that caused them to fall into financial ruins. Major banks took wild, high risk actions on loans that were highly questionable only to have the Federal government bail them out. Insurer AIG has already sucked up almost $200 billion of taxpayer money and was likely used as a funnel for taxpayer money to the big banks balance sheets for their non-due diligence in insuring risky real estate loans. The Federal government had to bail itself out because of its mismanagement of Fannie Mae and Freddie Mac, again wasting billions of taxpayer dollars.

The one thing that all of these entities had in common, the car companies, the banks, the insurance companies, and the government housing entities, was that they took unnecessary risks and made very poor decisions but did not go to business/financial hell, they simply got taxpayers to foot the bill. And we are about to do the same thing again. According to an Associated Press report from February 12, 2010, President Obama will soon announce that the Federal government, using taxpayer money, will provide $54.5 billion in loan guarantees to companies that will build the next set of nuclear energy plants in the country. This amount of money is enough to build about 6-7 new plants and serve 1.4 million people. It should also support full time jobs for 850 people and employ 3,000 construction workers.

Supporters of the loan guarantee state that without the government backing the construction of new nuclear plants, nothing will get done because of the high upfront costs. Critics of the plan state that it is nothing more than another government subsidy of a private industry and that given the history of cost and schedule overruns in the industry, the $54.5 billion price tag might be too low. Some environmentalists also oppose the plan since new nuclear plants will result in additional dangerous nuclear waste, for which the government does not have a plan for safe storage and removal.

The fact that the plants will not get built without a Federal guarantee of loans, as the supporters of Obama's plan claim, should tell you something from a free market perspective. If no one in the private sector is willing to put down the capital and effort to build a new nuclear plant because of the high risks, why do we think it is such a great idea for the Federal government to support and guarantee it with taxpayer money? The economics are still the same and if private industry does not like the economics, it certainly will not be better economics if the Federal government is involved. It sounds a lot like the past year's bailouts, "don't worry, if you fail, we will keep you whole with free taxpayer money." Remember, capitalism without the threat of bankruptcy is like Christianity without the threat of hell.

Plus, is this really the right way to go from an energy strategy perspective? Let's do some math:
  • The Federal government will be on the hook for $54.5 billion which comes out to a per household cost of about $420. Thus, is it a good deal for those millions of households that will not be served by these 6-7 new nuclear plants to put up this amount of their money to subsidize the energy costs for 1.4 million?
  • According to the U.S. census organization, the average U.S. household consists of 2.61 people so that the 1.4 million people that will be served by these new plants will live in only 537,000 homes. Thus, 130 million U.S. households will be theoretically paying $420 each to subsidize 537,000 households, which represents only .4% of all households.
  • As with all government programs, the economic positives, i.e. more jobs, will be focused around the sites of the new nuclear plants. Thus, 6-7 local areas will see new jobs at the expense of the rest of the country.
  • And worse of all does, this make any sense relative to other energy formats? According to an online PBS article associated with its Nova television show, a complete solar energy retrofit they did to a house in southern California cost about $61,500. This retrofit made the house completely solar powered and actually returned excess electrical energy generated by the retrofit into the utility's power grid. Now if we assume that this real life example is a good estimate of the cost to solar retrofit a typical American home, then that $54.5 billion loan guarantee would be able to make about 866,000 U.S. homes cleanly energy independent, 65% more than the number of homes served by the 6-7 new nuclear plants. Seems like a better deal to me.
There a number of additional advantages of using that money for solar retrofits than trying to build highly complex, dangerous nuclear power plants:
  1. First, you can effect more homes than the nuclear approach making any use of taxpayer money more efficient.
  2. Second, you do not have that pesky increase in dangerous radioactive waste that you would have the nuclear power plants.
  3. Third, you would still have a lot of jobs created, countering the jobs needed to run and build the nuclear plants, but those solar manufacturing and installation jobs would be more fairly spread around the country and not focused just around those 6-7 plants.
  4. Fourth, the costs used in the above calculation was for one retrofit. However, if it became worthwhile to do thousands of retrofits, the cost of materials and installation would likely fall dramatically, allowing for more retrofits.
  5. Fifth, what if the $54.5 billion was used to only pay for half the cost of the retrofits and the homeowner was required to put some equity into the retrofit? If so, then the number of clean, solar retrofitted homes could be as high as 1.7 million households, much more than the 536,000 homes served by the nuclear plants.
  6. Fifth, if the taxpayer was going to foot the bill for these retrofits, the costs would be spread out over years and would be incurred as the work was done, it would not be risked in an all or nothing up front bet like the back the nuclear plants. If households wanted to retrofit their house for solar, than part of that $54.5 billion could be used to pay for the retrofit. Money paid when the costs were incurred as opposed to money paid to the nuclear power plant builders, in the form of loan guarantees, before any costs were incurred.
  7. The impact on the nation's energy situation could be almost immediate as home owners started their retrofits with today's technology while it would likely take many years before these nuclear plants are up and running.
As with most government programs, I always wonder if anyone in the political class does the simple math to figure out what the true picture of spending taxpayer money is. (Remember our calculation the other day showing that the Obama stimulus plan cost the country about a quarter of a million dollars to create one job). Same thing here, why risk billions of dollars for an enivornmentally risky solution when some simple math would show a far better, quicker and fairer solution exists? It all comes down to the political class not knowing how to solve any problems. Thus, that is why Step 23 in "Love My Country, Loathe My Government" is so important. Step 23 would put together a panel of smart American experts (akin to historical panels that actually got something done in Washington including the Manhattan Project, the Apollo space mission, the Grace Commission on government, the military base closing commission, etc.) to develop and implement a comprehensive energy strategy for the country, i.e. do the math and analysis.

The political class has been looking at the energy situation in this country since the oil embargoes of the 1970s and has accomplished nothing. Throwing tens of billions of dollars at nuclear power plant construction companies accomplishes nothing without the context of an overall energy strategy and understanding the trade offs between all types of factors. Step 23 would accomplish that feat and if done right, would solve the problem and not waste the taxpayer money doing so.



Visit our website at www.loathemygovernment.com to order an autographed copy of the book, "Love My Country, Loathe My Government -Fifty First Steps To Restoring Our Freedom and Destroying The American Political Class" and to sign up for the cause. The book is also available online at Amazon and Barnes And Noble.